Miracle on 34th Street: The Musical Cast Announced!

Director Amanda Ellis and Music Director Dan Ognavic have announced the cast for STC’s second musical of the season.

Single mother Doris Walker (Tracie Wessels) doesn’t want her six-year-old Susan’s (Juliana Wetzel) head filled with romantic notions. Their neighbor, Fred Gailey (Adam Guenther), tries to woo Doris by charming Susan and taking her to see Santa Claus at Macy’s, where Doris works. Doris is not impressed, but when it turns out that Macy’s Santa may, in fact, be the real Kris Kringle (Steve Myers), a wave of love spreads across New York City that melts even the most cynical hearts.

Complete cast list:

Susan Walker Juliana Wetzel

Doris Walker Tracie Wessels

Kris Kringle Steve Myers

Fred Gaily Adam Guenther

R.H. Macy Duncan Doherty

Shellhammer David Quinn

Ms. Beeler Michelle Bestul

Judge/Mayor Bernie Starzewski

DA/Mr. Gimbal/Clown Brad Leonhardt

Sawyer/Tammany/Alvin/Police #2 Timmy Wiverstad

Drunk Santa/Mailman Mike Eberhardy

Harry Finfer Josiah Guenther

Tommy Mara Jr./kid AJ Kaufman

Climber/Bailiff/Police #1/Night Watchman Eric Eberhardy


Henrika Bella Rudell

Miss Crookshank Elizabeth Plotka-Heinen

Henrika’s Mother/Miss Sims Susan Salm

Clara/Vendor Michelle Guenther

Clerk #1 Mary Luke

Clerk #2 Alison Guenther

Clerk #3/Girl Scout Alex Spielvogel

Mrs. Finfer Michelle Guenther



Alison Guenther

Autumn Schultz

Bella Rudell

Natalie Plate

Alyson LaPoint

Alex Blindauer

Shannon Meyer

Rebecca Shvartsman

Daisy Wilson

Danielle Wilson

Dakota Ortiz